Columbus, Ohio — Investigations are underway into allegations that a doctor working for an Ohio hospital system ordered inappropriately high doses of pain medication to dozens of patients, leading to the deaths of at least 28 people at two hospitals.
The Columbus-area Mount Carmel Hospital System has said six other patients under the care of Dr. William Husel received doses of fentanyl that were larger than necessary to provide comfort, but likely weren’t the cause of their deaths. The patients who died under Husel’s care suffered from various ailments and ranged in age from 39 to 83.
The hospital system has acknowledged that Husel wasn’t removed from patient care until four weeks after concerns were raised about his prescribing habits. Three patients died during those weeks after receiving excessive fentanyl doses ordered by Husel, Mount Carmel said.
The hospital has apologized and has placed six pharmacists and 14 nurses on administrative leave during the investigation. Neither Husel nor his attorneys have commented about the allegations.
CBS affiliate WBNS-TV reports Christine Allison says she is grieving the loss of her husband, Troy Allison. Her attorneys, Craig Tuttle and Gerald Leeseberg, said the 44-year old excavator died within hours of being at Mount Carmel West hospital.
Part of his medical record supplied by the attorneys shows that Troy Allison had been given 1,000 micrograms of fentanyl, a lethal dose, the attorneys allege.
“There’s too much here to concede that this was an accident,” Leeseberg told reporters during a news conference at his Columbus law office Thursday.
“I want to know what happened. I want answers,” Christine Allison said. “I’m still in shock.”
Timeline shows investigation of alleged pain meds overdosing
A review of events so far based on information provided by Mount Carmel Hospital System, details in lawsuits and accounts from patients’ family members:
Oct. 25: Columbus-based Mount Carmel receives formal report related to care provided by Husel.
Nov. 19: Mount Carmel receives second formal report related to Husel’s care and broadens an internal investigation.
Nov. 21: Mount Carmel receives a third report and prohibits Husel from providing patient care.
Dec. 5: Mount Carmel fires Husel, notifies the State Medical Board of Ohio and meets with Franklin County Prosecutor Ron O’Brien. Two days later, the hospital notifies the Ohio Boards of Pharmacy & Nursing.
Dec. 11: Mount Carmel begins training staff on changes in procedures and on existing and updated policies.
Dec. 27: Mount Carmel first contacts families of patients affected by Husel’s actions to notify them and apologize.
Jan. 14: The first lawsuit is filed over the deaths, against the health system, a pharmacist, a nurse, and Husel, alleging a “grossly excessive” dosage of the powerful painkiller fentanyl was ordered to hasten the death of 79-year-old Janet Kavanaugh in December 2017.
The same day, allegations against Husel become public as the hospital system releases a statement revealing the deaths of 27 patients who received doses of pain medication that were potentially fatal. The hospital’s President and CEO Ed Lamb apologizes and says they are investigating how it happened. In an internal video released to employees the same day, Lamb said Husel’s orders were carried out by employees who “made poor decisions” and ignored existing safeguards.
Jan. 16: In the first public comments from a family member, David Austin, of Columbus, says he felt “like somebody kicked me in the chest” when he was told of the alleged circumstances of the death of his wife of 36 years, Bonnie Austin, in September. The same day, Mount Carmel says it identified a 28th patient. Attorneys for Husel issue their first “no comment.”
Jan. 17: The widow of a man treated by Husel says news of the circumstances of her husband’s death left her shocked that such a scenario could happen despite procedural and technological safeguards. Christine Allison, of Columbus, says “the system failed tremendously” in the case of her 44-year-old husband, Troy.
Jan. 19: The Ohio Department of Health confirms its investigation of Husel on behalf of the U.S. Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services.
Jan. 24: Mount Carmel acknowledges that Husel kept working for four weeks after concern was raised last fall. It also says it is now investigating whether some patients got excessive doses while they might still have had the opportunity to improve with treatment. The hospital raises the total number of patients receiving excessive doses of pain medication to 34.
Jan. 25: State Medical Board suspends Husel’s license, says doctor invoked his right against self-incrimination when he met with representatives this week and was questioned. Two additional lawsuits filed, over the deaths of 69-year-old Joanne Bellisari in May 2015 and 80-year-old Jim Allen in May 2018, bringing the total to six lawsuits as of Friday.